ÿWPCÑ ÃÊö¸öd§* İ›["؈iFÙtÔ·¿Ï«E­h—†µvÃ:ì`\Gų3ǧ‹½ÿù³ÅçÒ°¨ı( ~›¬WÓÑ’´Û)« Îı³ÎgVy<ë¢ã¹å7Š’zj§4ReÏ™ã  ¹YÂQ*Wc ÔEÃG„Óç)‰‡Œˆ0!1ê‰=¦P›L+ã'ºUñËÜ…Up+©Ü€.¸†ÉA––›Y÷––§[àOñËV Ş<-8U×W~5“ÓÚu”˜ßL2ÖüÕæ:¤!w8¾± WÒ'>ÌF{00㜡4—R ?İÓC±á~“’‹Eå0É$_s((Ço¨”f¥ïğ8İ4‡¬]h­™\4¾€˜'¹¤qµ€ö®nGÄÏÆÙÇÁe¬W±ê×ÓøäâWfÀ:FW}YÕNEÛ_ Ãûªyáğ*¨µX㪛&:–©Ë×Bè½(«ş˜µsŸ×U;ú´œ%êÍÖ,H' % ˆA–Ë.Ù”ˆŠ²Qv$y6Ë&u‡•DOÉ|¦”$µX‚ò©»iäGˆ6WùV8 ³ğ€1¡‘Á€·`»»÷ü3"X·Ãñÿ÷ô&ë+ü[ÌN­ÏÖƒ¿§‚²É¹IËkez9(#Á0UNñ %? 0:E^ w‹4£² m´ 1‡Ë 72R 1u„ 72ù 0sc+ 0w 01Š 1‡ 72 0 H 0´è 0Çœ 0Ûc 0ï> 0D- 1‡q 72ø 1‡* 72± 1‡ã 72j 1‡œ 72# 1‡U 72Ü 1‡ 72•NÇɘNEC SuperScript 870ğğğğğğğğ0(ÖÃ9 Z‹6Times New Roman RegularX(üœ$¡¡ÔUSUS.,Ô§˜',â N›Ì*ê:i¢×+003|x ÿU‹ÿÀÀÀ0gACEKQU[agmAutoList11.1.21.1.1.1.1. 1.3#37=CIQYag­­1.a.i.(1)(a)(i)1)a) i)(;3£$´´Ô2#ÔÚ  Ú0Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  à(Oé;$µµà0  àÔ2#ÔÚ  ÚaÚ  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0` (#(#à(b·¤$¶¶à0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2#ÔÚ  ÚÚ  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àpî(CEIMQUY]aAutoList222222222i)1)a)2(xir$··à0  àà0` (#(#àà0¸ ` (#` (#àÔ2#Ô(Ú  Ú0Ú  Ú)Ô3  Ôà0¸ (#¸ (#à(ŒÜ$¸¸à0  àà0` (#(#àà0¸ ` (#` (#àà0¸ (#¸ (#àÔ2#Ô(Ú  ÚaÚ  Ú)Ô3  Ôà0h(#(#à(ŸF$¹¹à0  àà0` (#(#àà0¸ ` (#` (#àà0¸ (#¸ (#àà0h(#(#àÔ2#Ô(Ú  ÚÚ  Ú)Ô3  Ôà0Àh(#h(#à(³Àô$ººà0  àà0` (#(#àà0¸ ` (#` (#àà0¸ (#¸ (#àà0h(#(#àà0Àh(#h(#àÔ2#ÔÚ  Ú0Ú  Ú)Ô3  Ôà0À(#À(#à(ǵ{$»»à0  àà0` (#(#àà0¸ ` (#` (#àà0¸ (#¸ (#àà0h(#(#àà0Àh(#h(#àà0À(#À(#àÔ2#ÔÚ  ÚaÚ  Ú)Ô3  Ôà0p(#(#à(F$ïïà0  àà0` (#(#àà0¸ ` (#` (#àà0¸ (#¸ (#àà0h(#(#àà0Àh(#h(#àà0À(#À(#àà0p(#(#àÔ2#ÔÙ ÙÚ  ÚÚ  ÚÙ Ù)Ô3  Ôà0Èp(#p(#àÙ Ù0ç;CEKOU[agmAutoList31.21.1.1.1.1.1.1.h)CEIMQUY]aAutoList422222222i)1)a)20ï;CEKOU[agmAutoList51.21.1.1.1.1.1.1.h.)CEIMQUY]aAutoList622222222i)1)a) 2(•hCEKQW]cioAutoList71.1.1.1.1.1.1.1."1.(¥hCEKQW]cioAutoList81.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.$1. İ ƒüœ!İÔUSUS.,Ôİ  İÔ_ÔÑ8€yµXXdğdÈ8Ñò òÓ  ÓDRAFT€WRAP€Meeting€Minutesó óĞ ° ĞNovember€14€„€15,€2001Ğ  ğ ĞSalt€Lake€City,€UtahĞ à ĞÓxÓÌò òWednesday€November€14ó óĞ pÀ ĞÌÓ€ $(¥h83 ÓGovernor€Cyrus€Chino€called€the€meeting€to€order€at€1:10Ğ P   ĞÌÓ€ (gA08$Óİ"‚3£"İİ  İİ‚3£œİÔ2gAÔÚ  Ú1Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òReview€of€agendaó óóó.€€There€were€no€comments€on€the€agenda.݃3£œÉİŒĞ0 €(#(# ĞŒİ  İÌİ"‚3£"İİ  İİ‚3£ªİÔ2gAÔÚ  Ú2Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òApproval€of€minutes€from€May€2001€Board€Meetingó óóó.€€There€were€no€changes€to€theĞ h  Ğminutes.€€The€minutes€were€approved€unanimously.݃3£ª×İŒĞ` (#(# ĞŒİ  İÌİ"‚3£"İİ  İİ‚3£İÔ2gAÔÚ  Ú3Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òCharter€modification€to€include€Alaskaó óóó.€€Dianne€Nielson€announced€that€GovernorĞ ğ@  ĞKnowles€had€requested€membership€for€Alaska€in€the€WRAP.€€Andy€Ginsburg€said€thatĞ è8  Ğincluding€the€State€of€Alaska€would€help€efforts€to€provide€clean€air€and€protect€Class€IĞ Ø( Ğareas.€€He€urged€the€Board€to€support€the€request.€€The€Board€unanimously€approvedĞ È Ğinclusion€of€Alaska€in€the€WRAP.€€Tom€Chapple€from€the€Alaska€DEQ€joined€the€WRAPĞ ¸ ĞBoard€at€the€meeting.݃3£@݌Шø(#(# ĞŒİ  İÌİ"‚3£"İİ  İİ‚3£İÔ2gAÔÚ  Ú4Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òIOC€and€TOC€appointmentsó óóó.€€State€and€tribal€recommendations€for€filling€expiringĞ ˆØ Ğappointments€were€distributed€to€the€Board.€€Bill€Grantham€noted€that€Julie€Simpson€wasĞ €Ğ Ğpreviously€given€an€interim€appointment€to€the€IOC.€€He€requested€that€this€appointmentĞ pÀ Ğbe€confirmed€for€a€three„year€term€expiring€on€December€31,€2004€and€that€Julie€replaceĞ `° ĞKesner€Flores€as€a€co„chair€of€the€IOC.€€Kesner€will€continue€as€an€IOC€member.€€Bill€alsoĞ P  Ğrequested€approval€of€Ondrea€Barber€to€the€TOC€for€a€three„year€term.€€Nancy€WronaĞ @ Ğasked€that€the€present€state€co„chairs€of€the€IOC€and€TOC€be€given€one€year€extensions€toĞ 0€ Ğtheir€terms€and€continue€in€their€positions.€€Ernie€Wessman€of€Pacificorp€was€previouslyĞ  p Ğgiven€an€interim€appointment€and€it€was€requested€that€his€appointment€be€confirmed.€Ğ ` ĞKesner€Flores€moved€and€Doug€Lempke€seconded€a€motion€to€approve€theĞ  P Ğappointments.€€The€motion€passed€unanimously.݃3£0İŒĞğ @(#(# ĞŒİ  İÌİ"‚3£"İİ  İİ‚3£# İÔ2gAÔÚ  Ú5Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òWelcoming€remarks€from€Governor€Michael€Leavittó óóó.€€Governor€Leavitt€noted€that€theĞ Ğ"   ĞWRAP€process€has€worked€and€expressed€hope€that€the€WRAP€will€continue€to€findĞ È#! Ğways€to€work€in€concert€with€all€stakeholders€to€protect€the€environment.݃3£# P ݌и$ "(#(# ĞŒİ  İÌİ"‚3£"İİ  İİ‚3£ İÔ2gAÔÚ  Ú6Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òAwards€to€members€of€the€Fire€Emissions€Joint€Forumó óóó.€€Darla€Potter,€Pete€Lahm€andĞ ˜&è!$ Ğother€members€of€the€Natural€Background€Task€Team€were€recognized€for€their€efforts€onĞ 'à"% Ğthe€FEJF€and€were€presented€certificates€by€Governors€Chino€and€Leavitt.݃3£ 8݌Ѐ(Ğ#&(#(# ĞŒİ  İÌİ"‚3£"İİ  İİ‚3£úİÔ2gAÔÚ  Ú7Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òStatus€of€Annexó óóó.€€Jack€McGraw€from€EPA€Region€VIII€provided€an€update€on€the€AnnexĞ `*°%( Ğreview€and€approval€process.€€EPA€expects€to€send€the€Annex€to€the€Office€ofĞ X+¨&) ĞManagement€and€Budget€the€week€of€November€19òòthóó.€€OMB€has€a€90„day€review€periodĞ ° Ğbefore€EPA€sends€it€out€for€public€comment.€€A€final€rule€is€expected€during€the€summerĞ  ğ Ğof€2002.€€McGraw€said€the€Administration€supports€the€Annex€and€intends€to€keep€it€onĞ à Ğtrack€for€a€speedy€approval.݃3£ú'݌ЀĞ(#(# ĞŒİ  İÌİ"‚3£"İİ  İİ‚3£õİÔ2gAÔÚ  Ú8Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òMulti„pollutant€billó óóó.€€Dianne€Nielson€provided€a€status€report€of€the€U.S.€Senate€hearingsĞ ` ° Ğand€the€Administration€proposal.€€She€noted€that€WRAP€members€have€provided€input€toĞ X ¨ Ğthe€Senate€committee.€€She€suggested€the€WRAP€agree€on€a€process€for€providingĞ H ˜ Ğinformation€to€legislative€committees€and€keeping€WRAP€members€informed€ofĞ 8 ˆ Ğdevelopments€on€any€federal€legislation.€€İƒ3£õ"İŒĞ( x (#(# ĞŒİ  İÌà0  àJack€McGraw€said€an€Administration€bill€is€not€likely€to€be€introduced€for€at€least€a€year.€Ğ X  ĞEPA€is€most€concerned€about€how€to€effectively€attack€the€problems€and€is€not€justĞ øH  Ğlooking€at€new€regulation.€€Discussions€are€now€focused€on€developing€a€conceptualĞ è8  Ğapproach€to€problem„solving.€€He€assured€the€Board€that€the€concerns€of€the€West€areĞ Ø(  Ğbeing€heard€at€headquarters€and€would€be€considered€in€developing€any€approach.€€ĞÈ(#(# ĞÌà0  àAndy€Ginsburg€said€that€Oregon€and€Washington€were€developing€a€letter€similar€to€theĞ ¨ø Ğone€already€sent€by€Governor€Leavitt,€which€would€emphasize€the€need€for€the€WesternĞ ˜è ĞStates€to€speak€with€one€voice€on€this€important€issue.€€€ĞˆØ(#(# ĞÌà0  àRichard€Long€of€EPA€Region€VIII€re„emphasized€that€current€EPA€efforts€are€aimed€atĞ h¸ Ğcreating€a€bill€that€works€for€the€Senate,€the€Administration,€and€the€States.€€EPA€testifiedĞ X¨ Ğat€the€Senate€Environment€and€Public€Works€Committee€hearing€on€November€1.€€TheĞ H˜ Ğcurrent€Senate€bill€focuses€on€four€pollutants:€SO2,€NOx,€Mercury€and€CO2.€€He€saidĞ 8ˆ Ğthere€is€a€need€to€develop€a€trading€program€as€part€of€this€approach.€€The€AdministrationĞ (x Ğbelieves€the€bill€now€before€the€Senate€lacks€coordination€with€other€Clean€Air€ActĞ h Ğrequirements€and€is€leaning€toward€a€three€pollutant€bill,€excluding€CO2.€€TheĞ X ĞAdministration€supports€the€use€of€a€market€based,€cap„and„trade€system,€modeled€alongĞ øH Ğthe€lines€of€the€existing€SO2€trading€program.€€Ğè8(#(# ĞÌà0  àGovernor€Leavitt€asked€what€the€status€of€the€existing€legislation€was€and€how€that€wouldĞ È! Ğcoordinate€with€the€Administration€bill.€€EPA€responded€that€it€was€not€clear€how€quicklyĞ ¸"  Ğthe€existing€bill€would€move€forward,€but€that€EPA€would€be€working€with€the€Senate€toĞ ¨#ø! Ğdevelop€a€more€supportable€bipartisan€bill.€Ğ˜$è"(#(# ĞÌà0  àChris€Shaver€asked€whether€EPA€would€be€able€to€provide€assistance€to€the€WRAP€if€itĞ x&È!$ Ğdecides€to€develop€proposals€more€pertinent€to€the€West.€€Long€responded€that€EPAĞ h'¸"% Ğwould€most€likely€devote€time€to€addressing€Western€proposals.€€ĞX(¨#&(#(# ĞÌà0  àAndy€Ginsburg€said€that€by€supporting€the€Annex,€the€WRAP€recognizes€the€value€ofĞ 8*ˆ%( Ğimplementing€a€cap„and„trade€program.€€However,€there€is€still€concern€about€dealingĞ (+x&) Ğwith€localized€impacts€and€ensuring€that€real€reductions€are€achieved€in€the€West.€€LongĞ ,h'* Ğsaid€that€EPA€is€aware€of€the€issue€and€that€it€would€have€to€be€considered€in€greaterĞ ° Ğdetail€during€the€development€phase.€€Ğ ğ(#(# ĞÌà0  àDennis€Hemmer€said€that€it€would€be€important€to€develop€cost€and€emission€reductionĞ €Ğ Ğestimates€for€all€the€pollutants€the€Administration€is€considering€in€order€to€have€a€higherĞ pÀ Ğcomfort€level€for€making€decisions.€€Ğ` °(#(# ĞÌà0  àGovernor€Chino€asked€what€the€best€way€would€be€for€EPA€to€provide€assistance€to€theĞ @  Ğtribes€in€order€to€have€tribal€governments€be€fuller€participants.€€Long€suggested€that€itĞ 0 € Ğwould€be€best€for€the€tribes€to€bring€any€issues€they€have€before€the€Senate€committee.Ğ  p  ĞMcGraw€also€noted€that€EPA€has€a€mechanism€in€place€internally€for€the€tribes€to€provideĞ `  Ğinput.€€Kesner€Flores€said€that€the€tribes€would€work€on€the€development€of€a€positionĞ P  Ğpaper€to€ensure€tribal€perspectives€on€issues€were€clearly€identified.€€Ğğ@ (#(# ĞÌà0  àBob€Neufeld€from€Wyoming€Refining€Co.€asked€where€the€Administration€was€movingĞ Ğ  Ğon€allocation€schemes.€€Long€said€he€is€not€privy€to€any€discussions€on€the€issue.€€ĞÀ(#(# ĞÌà0  àLewis€McLeod€said€that€the€tribes€would€have€resource€problems€if€the€EPA€moved€awayĞ  ğ Ğfrom€PM10€and€more€toward€NOx€and€Mercury.€€He€asked€if€tribal€environmentalĞ à Ğprograms€could€expect€sufficient€funding€to€deal€with€NOx€and€Mercury€issues.€€LongĞ €Ğ Ğsaid€a€review€of€€funding€allocations€is€always€part€of€the€funding€process,€but€that€it€isĞ pÀ Ğunlikely€a€multi„pollutant€bill€will€have€a€specific€effect€on€tribal€funding.€€Jill€Sherman€re„Ğ `° Ğemphasized€the€need€to€adequately€involve€the€tribes€and€to€make€sure€tribal€leaders€areĞ P  Ğpersonally€contacted€to€determine€what€their€specific€issues€are.€€Ğ@(#(# ĞÌà0  àThe€Board€discussed€possible€next€steps€with€regard€to€maintaining€an€appropriateĞ  p Ğinvolvement€in€the€development€of€legislation€and€the€facilitation€of€information€sharing.€Ğ ` ĞHemmer€said€the€first€thing€the€WRAP€needed€to€focus€on€was€whether€there€was€anĞ P Ğaccurate€inventory€of€emissions€available.€€He€said€the€WRAP€should€generate€a€workĞ ğ@ Ğplan€to€develop€such€an€inventory€and€to€determine€what€would€be€the€impacts€of€variousĞ à0 Ğlevels€of€reduction.€€ĞĞ (#(# ĞÌà0  àNielson€asked€if€the€Market€Trading€Forum€was€working€on€development€of€inventoryĞ °"  Ğinformation.€€Colleen€Delaney€said€that€the€WRAP€work€plan€for€2002€€focuses€more€onĞ  #ğ! ĞPM€and€NOx.€€She€also€said€the€MTF€would€examine€what€controls€are€on€sources€andĞ $à" Ğhow€much€reduction€could€be€achieved€from€further€control€strategies.€€McLeod€notedĞ €%Ğ # Ğthat€tribal€inventory€data€is€lacking€and€that€it€is€important€to€find€ways€to€make€tribal€dataĞ p&À!$ Ğmore€complete.€€Ğ`'°"%(#(# ĞÌà0  àShaver€said€€it€is€important€to€have€the€IOC€and€TOC€come€up€with€a€list€of€questions€toĞ @)$' Ğdetermine€if€a€context€exists€in€which€the€WRAP€could€forward€its€issues.€€Hemmer€re„Ğ 0*€%( Ğemphasized€the€need€to€have€a€proposal€on€what€can€be€done€to€develop€the€informationĞ  +p&) Ğneeded€to€make€informed€decisions.€€Nielson€suggested€having€the€IOC€and€TOC€co„Ğ ,`'* Ğchairs€look€at€what€information€is€available€on€inventory€numbers€and€have€them€suggestĞ ° Ğa€mechanism€to€track€the€issue€and€develop€a€set€of€western€principles.€€Bob€SaundersĞ  ğ Ğsuggested€that€the€Air€Managers€Group€could€provide€important€input€into€the€process.€Ğ à ĞAndy€Ginsburg€agreed€to€work€with€Bill€Grantham€and€Patrick€Cummins€to€develop€aĞ €Ğ Ğschedule.ĞpÀ(#(# ĞÌİ"‚3£"İİ  İİ‚3£2İÔ2gAÔÚ  Ú9Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òStatus€of€Public€Advisory€Boardó óóó.€€Barry€Aarons€made€the€presentation.€€He€said€there€areĞ P   Ğtwo€issues.€The€first€is€public€outreach.€€The€second€is€whether€the€PAB€is€the€properĞ H ˜ Ğforum€in€which€to€approach€public€outreach.€€Barry€said€that€in€the€Grand€CanyonĞ 8 ˆ ĞVisibility€Transport€Commission€process,€there€was€a€single€issue€everyone€was€drivingĞ ( x  Ğtoward,€making€the€PAB€an€effective€way€of€doing€public€outreach.€€However,€for€theĞ h  ĞWRAP,€it€seems€more€effective€for€the€Forums€to€be€the€focus€of€public€outreach€with€theĞ X  Ğassistance€of€the€Communications€Committee.€€The€Communications€CommitteeĞ øH  Ğrecommends€inviting€the€members€of€the€PAB€to€become€members€of€theĞ è8  ĞCommunications€Committee.€€The€Committee€is€also€recommending€that€the€Charter€beĞ Ø(  Ğamended€to€eliminate€the€PAB.€€The€Communications€Committee€will€discuss€appropriateĞ È Ğlanguage€and€present€it€to€the€Board€at€the€next€meeting.€€Kesner€Flores€requested€thatĞ ¸ Ğthere€be€a€better€mechanism€to€create€an€understanding€of€tribal€issues,€to€involve€theĞ ¨ø ĞCommunications€Committee€in€tribal€issues,€and€to€do€a€better€job€of€public€outreach€toĞ ˜è Ğthe€tribes.݃3£2F2݌ЈØ(#(# ĞŒİ  İÌİ"‚3£ "İİ  İİ‚3£@8İÔ2gAÔÚ  Ú10Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òWork€Plan€Overview€and€Financial€Status€Reportó óóó.€€Patrick€Cummins€and€Bill€GranthamĞ h¸ Ğpresented€the€overview.€(slide€show€presentation€and€full€Work€Plan€Update€are€availableĞ `° Ğon€the€WRAP€Web€site)݃3£@8m8İŒĞP (#(# ĞŒİ  İÌİ"‚3£ "İİ  İİ‚3£:İÔ2gAÔÚ  Ú11Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òCommunications€Committee€Updateó óóó.€€Barry€Aarons€discussed€the€status€of€the€SpeakersĞ 0€ ĞBureau.€€He€noted€that€a€speaker€recruitment€goal€has€been€established€to€increase€theĞ (x Ğnumber€of€available€speakers.€€He€said€the€goal€of€the€speakers€bureau€was€to€haveĞ h ĞWRAP€issues€presented€at€least€three€times€in€the€six€largest€cities€in€the€first€quarter€ofĞ X Ğ2002.€€He€asked€that€WRAP€members€who€wished€to€make€presentations€to€groups€theyĞ øH Ğare€members€of€should€make€it€known€and€materials€will€be€sent€to€them.€€Al€ZemskyĞ è 8 Ğhighlighted€two€projects€from€the€work€plan.€€First,€he€noted€the€Web€site€is€very€activeĞ Ø!( Ğand€is€successfully€being€used.€€He€also€noted€that€the€WRAP€electronic€newsletter€isĞ È"  Ğavailable€on€the€Web€site.€€Jan€Miller€reported€on€the€SIP/TIP€template€project.€€She€saidĞ ¸#! Ğthat€there€was€an€electronic€public€outreach€effort€being€done€through€the€Web€site.€€AĞ ¨$ø" Ğcomment€period€ran€for€six€weeks€ending€October€22.€€There€were€no€comments,€but€theĞ ˜%è # Ğprocess€used€to€solicit€comments€is€considered€fully€tested€and€available€to€be€used€onĞ ˆ&Ø!$ Ğfuture€projects.€€İƒ3£:-:İŒĞx'È"%(#(# ĞŒİ  İÌİ"‚3£ "İİ  İİ‚3£é?İÔ2gAÔÚ  Ú12Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òIOC/TOC€Reportó óóó.€€Andy€Ginsburg,€Mike€George,€Bobby€Ramirez,€and€Julie€SimpsonĞ X)¨$' Ğpresented€the€Work€Plan€update€for€the€IOC€and€TOC€Forums€(slide€presentationĞ P* %( Ğavailable€on€the€Web€site).€Major€discussion€points€included:݃3£é?@İŒĞ@+&)(#(# ĞŒİ  İĞ 0,€'* Ğİ"‚·¤ "İİ  İİ‚·¤ÕAİà0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2gAÔğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àİ  İcritical€path€elements݃·¤ÕAB݌а¸ (#¸ (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚·¤ "İİ  İİ‚·¤ÉBİà0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2gAÔğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àİ  İimportance€of€modeling€to€stay€on€the€critical€path݃·¤ÉBöB݌Рğ¸ (#¸ (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚·¤ "İİ  İİ‚·¤ÚCİà0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2gAÔğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àİ  İmajor€products€needed€for€2003€plans€İƒ·¤ÚCDİŒĞภ(#¸ (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚·¤ "İİ  İİ‚·¤İDİà0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2gAÔğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àİ  İclean€air€corridor€work݃·¤İD E݌Ѐи (#¸ (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚·¤ "İİ  İİ‚·¤ÒEİà0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2gAÔğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àİ  İannex€related€work€to€be€done€by€the€Market€Trading€Forum.݃·¤ÒEÿEİŒĞpÀ¸ (#¸ (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚·¤ "İİ  İİ‚·¤êFİà0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2gAÔğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àİ  İneed€for€NOx€and€PM€milestones,€and€potential€benefits€if€the€are€needed݃·¤êFGİŒĞ` °¸ (#¸ (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚·¤ "İİ  İİ‚·¤Hİà0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2gAÔğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àİ  İMobile€Source€Forum€work݃·¤H=HİŒĞP  ¸ (#¸ (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚·¤ "İİ  İİ‚·¤Iİà0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2gAÔğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àİ  İrequirements€for€fire€İƒ·¤I3IİŒĞ@ ¸ (#¸ (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚·¤ "İİ  İİ‚·¤úIİà0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2gAÔğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àİ  İroad€dust€work݃·¤úI'JİŒĞ0 €¸ (#¸ (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚·¤  "İİ  İİ‚·¤æJİà0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2gAÔğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àİ  İpollution€prevention€work݃·¤æJK݌Рp ¸ (#¸ (# ĞŒİ  İÌà0  àRamirez€reported€on€some€additional€technical€issues€(slide€presentation€available€on€WebĞ P  Ğsite)€includingĞğ@ (#(# ĞÌÓ€ (î(x0  Óİ"‚·¤"İİ  İİ‚·¤Mİà0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2î(Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àİ  İTribal€Data€Development€Work€Group݃·¤M5MİŒĞĞ ¸ (#¸ (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚·¤"İİ  İİ‚·¤Nİà0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2î(Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àİ  İstatus€of€emissions€inventory€work݃·¤N5NİŒĞÀ¸ (#¸ (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚·¤"İİ  İİ‚·¤Oİà0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2î(Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àİ  İair€quality€modeling݃·¤O5O݌а¸ (#¸ (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚·¤"İİ  İİ‚·¤úOİà0  àà0` (#(#àÔ2î(Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0¸ ` (#` (#àİ  İambient€monitoring݃·¤úO'P݌Рğ¸ (#¸ (# ĞŒİ  İÌà0  àThe€Board€approved€the€2002€work€plan€and€grant€application€unanimously.Ğ€Ğ(#(# ĞÌòòThursday€November€15óóĞ `° Ğà  àà ` àà ¸ àà  àà h àà À àà  àà p àÌÓ€ (ç;0xÓØ! !Øİ"‚3£ "İİ  İİ‚3£‘RİÔ2ç;ÔÚ  Ú13Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òRecommended€policy€for€categorizing€fire€emissionsó óóó.€€Pete€Lahm€and€Darla€Potter€madeĞ @ Ğthe€presentation€(slide€presentation€available€on€Web€site).€€€Bob€Raisch€asked€about€theĞ 8ˆ Ğinput/coverage€with€regard€to€the€agricultural€sector.€€Pete€responded€that€the€agriculturalĞ (x Ğtask€force€was€consulted€and€that€there€was€representation€from€the€agriculturalĞ h Ğcommunity€on€the€task€team.€€The€agricultural€task€force€expressed€concern€with€theĞ X Ğimplications€of€the€policy€and€the€control€that€might€be€applied.€€However,€there€has€beenĞ øH Ğan€ongoing€effort€to€work€with€the€Agricultural€Task€Force€to€resolve€issues.€€İƒ3£‘R¾RİŒĞè8(#(# ĞŒİ  İÌà0  àLucille€Van€Ommering€asked€about€the€integration€of€the€regional€haze€goals€with€theĞ È! Ğother€goals€in€the€policy.€€Pete€responded€that€there€are€competing€objectives,€but€thatĞ ¸"  Ğthrough€the€development€of€the€policy,€the€need€to€tie€in€visibility€requirements€is€madeĞ ¨#ø! Ğovert.€€Ğ˜$è"(#(# ĞÌà0  àBob€Wilkosz€asked€if€there€was€any€scenario€where€agricultural€burning€could€beĞ x&È!$ Ğconsidered€natural.€€Pete€responded€that€in€general,€no,€for€row€crops€and€orchards€andĞ h'¸"% Ğsimilar€agricultural€uses.€€Doug€Lempke€asked€what€requirement€of€the€regional€haze€ruleĞ X(¨#& Ğwas€being€addressed€by€the€policy.€€Pete€responded€that€the€need€to€define€naturalĞ H)˜$' Ğbackground€and€to€account€for€fire€was€a€part€of€the€rule.€€This€policy€allows€forĞ 8*ˆ%( Ğconsistency€in€defining€what€is€natural€and€what€is€anthropogenic.€€Doug€also€asked€if€weĞ (+x&) Ğhad€a€specific€schedule€we€needed€to€meet€with€this€policy.€€Pete€said€that€it€Ô_ÔwasĞ ,h'* Ğnecessary€to€have€the€policy€in€place€so€that€necessary€technical€work€could€be€done.€Ğ ° ĞDoug€noted€that€some€states,€like€Colorado,€cannot€regulate€agricultural€sources.€€PeteĞ  ğ Ğresponded€that€the€policy€does€have€some€flexibility€in€how€states€would€approachĞ à Ğcontrol€of€smoke€from€agricultural€sources,€but€that€there€ultimately€may€be€some€legalĞ €Ğ Ğissues€states€will€have€to€address.€€ĞpÀ(#(# ĞÌà0  àLewis€Ô_ÔMcLeodÔ_Ô€asked€how€the€policy€benefits€places€in€the€region€that€do€not€haveĞ P   Ğjurisdiction€over€a€respective€agricultural€burn.€€Pete€responded€that€emissions€trackingĞ @  Ğwould€be€the€method€used€to€quantify€emissions€impacts.€€Lewis€elaborated€that€if€oneĞ 0 € Ğjurisdiction€defines€agricultural€burning€as€natural,€but€another€jurisdiction€defines€it€asĞ  p  Ğanthropogenic,€that€creates€a€potential€conflict.€€Andy€Ô_ÔGinsburgÔ_Ô€said€that€this€issue€wouldĞ `  Ğbe€covered€in€more€detail€in€the€presentation€on€the€transmittal€letter.€€ĞP (#(# ĞÌà0  àGovernor€Chino€asked€how€much€input€tribes€had€into€the€Task€Team.€€Pete€respondedĞ à0  Ğthat€there€was€a€substantial€amount€of€tribal€participation.ĞĞ (#(# ĞÌà0  àAndy€Ô_ÔGinsburgÔ_Ô€presented€the€Transmittal€Letter€from€the€IOC€on€the€recommendedĞ ° Ğpolicy€(slide€presentation€available€on€web€site).€€There€were€some€areas€that€neededĞ  ğ Ğadditional€clarification€including:Ğà(#(# ĞÌÓ€ ()x0 Óİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£ıaİÔ2)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İdistinction€between€managed€and€controlled݃3£ıa6bİŒĞpÀ` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£ñbİÔ2)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İdistinction€between€ecosystem€maintenance€and€ecosystem€restoration݃3£ñb*cİŒĞ`°` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£şcİÔ2)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İcoordination€and€consistency€between€states€(need€to€address€this€in€theĞ P  Ğimplementation€guidance€to€the€policy)݃3£şc7dİŒĞ@` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£KeİÔ2)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İalternate€approach€to€data€flagging݃3£Ke„eİŒĞ0€` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£8fİÔ2)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İneed€to€address€tribal€concerns€about€adding€cultural€resources€to€decision€process݃3£8fqf݌Рp` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£UgİÔ2)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İdevelopment€of€recommendations€for€non„mandatory€Class€I€areas݃3£UggİŒĞ`` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£]hİÔ2)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İdevelopment€of€recommendations€for€establishing€emission€goals€for€fire݃3£]h–hİŒĞP` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£niİÔ2)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İprovision€of€clear€steps€for€incorporating€policy€management€elements€into€fireĞ ğ@ Ğprograms݃3£ni§iİŒĞà0` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İà0  àĞ (#(# Ğà0  àLucille€Van€Ô_ÔOmmeringÔ_Ô€asked€about€the€establishment€of€emission€goals.€€Andy€said€thatĞ À! Ğit€was€a€requirement€of€Section€309€to€establish€them€through€2018.€€€€Ğ°" (#(# ĞÌà0  àDoug€Ô_ÔLempkeÔ_Ô€asked€what€the€Ô_ÔtimelineÔ_Ô€was€for€developing€implementation€guidance.€Ğ $à" ĞPete€Ô_ÔLahmÔ_Ô€responded€that€it€was€targeted€for€June€2002.€€Dianne€Ô_ÔNielsonÔ_Ô€suggested€thatĞ €%Ğ # Ğthe€Board€could€direct€the€Ô_ÔFEFJÔ_Ô€to€consider€the€transmittal€letter€from€the€IOC€to€theĞ p&À!$ ĞBoard€during€the€development€of€the€implementation€policy.€€Dennis€Ô_ÔHemmerÔ_Ô€said€thatĞ `'°"% Ğthe€policy€can€recognize€that€states€may€have€legal€issues€in€tracking€agriculturalĞ P( #& Ğemissions,€but€at€the€same€time€allowing€estimations€to€suffice€to€meet€the€requirementsĞ @)$' Ğof€the€policy.€€Andy€suggested€that€the€transmittal€letter€could€be€made€an€Appendix€toĞ 0*€%( Ğthe€policy,€with€some€changes€to€ğ ğclarification€8"€in€the€letter€to€reflect€the€need€to€doĞ  +p&) Ğemissions€estimates.€€Ğ,`'*(#(# ĞÔ_Ô‡à0  àLewis€McLeod€asked€how€the€policy€relates€to€transboundary€issues.€Pete€responded€thatĞ ° Ğthe€policy€helps€reinforce€classifications€and€interagency€agreements.€€Wayne€LeipoldĞ  ğ Ğsuggested€that€there€were€other€techniques€that€could€be€used€to€track€the€impacts€ofĞ à Ğburning€emissions.€€Bonnie€Thie€noted€that€there€was€a€report€issued€by€Region€X€onĞ €Ğ Ğagricultural€burning€that€will€be€posted€on€the€EPA€Web€site€this€week.€€ĞpÀ(#(# ĞÌà0  àBob€Neufeld€asked€to€clarify€when€a€wildland€fire€would€be€managed€for€resourceĞ P   Ğbenefits€(there€is€a€conscious€management€decision€that€the€fire€will€not€be€suppressedĞ @  Ğbecause€there€is€a€plan€in€place€and€there€are€larger€resource€objectives).€€Ğ0 €(#(# ĞÌà0  àThe€Board€agreed€to€accept€recommended€policy€with€the€incorporation€of€the€letter€fromĞ `  Ğthe€IOC€to€the€Board€as€part€of€the€policy.ĞP (#(# ĞÌà0  àThe€final€policy€will€be€posted€on€the€WRAP€Web€site.Ğà0 (#(# ĞÌÓ€ (ï;0xÓØ! !Øİ"‚3£ "İİ  İİ‚3£WuİÔ2ï;ÔÚ  Ú14Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òCoordination€with€USDA€and€Agricultural€Task€Forceó óóó.€€Rick€Sprott€provided€someĞ À Ğbackground€on€the€Task€Force.€€He€said€that€a€letter€had€been€prepared€from€the€WRAPĞ ¸ Ğto€the€USDA€seeking€greater€coordination€and€communication€on€agricultural€air€qualityĞ ¨ø Ğissues€of€mutual€concern.€€Andy€Ginsburg€asked€how€EPA€can€support€the€WRAP€inĞ ˜è Ğbuilding€a€better€relationship€with€USDA.€€Amy€Zimpfer€responded€that€EPA€has€alreadyĞ ˆØ Ğestablished€a€high€level€policy€position€to€advise€the€Administrator€on€agricultural€issues.€Ğ xÈ ĞShe€said€that€EPA€would€be€involved€with€the€process€and€would€facilitate€in€any€wayĞ h¸ Ğpossible.€€İƒ3£Wu„uİŒĞX¨(#(# ĞŒİ  İÌà0  àWarren€Harper€from€the€Forest€Service€asked€if€it€would€be€appropriate€to€address€theĞ 8ˆ Ğletter€to€both€USDA€and€EPA.€€The€Board€agreed€to€do€that.€€Warren€also€noted€that€thereĞ (x Ğwould€be€a€few€editorial€changes€that€he€would€pass€along€to€Rick€Sprott.€€AndyĞ h ĞGinsburg€also€suggested€that€the€Task€Force€be€invited€to€future€meetings.ĞX(#(# ĞÌİ"‚3£"İİ  İİ‚3£ÉzİÔ2ï;ÔÚ  Ú15Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òPresentation,€discussion€and€approval€of€recommended€policy€for€determining€mobileĞ è8 Ğsource€significance€in€the€context€of€Section€309.ó óóó€€John€Kowalczyk€made€theĞ à 0 Ğpresentation€(slide€show€available€on€the€Web€site).€€One€of€the€main€points€of€theĞ Ø!( Ğpresentation€is€that€there€needs€to€be€more€work€on€the€definition€of€significant€and,€onceĞ È"  Ğconsensus€has€been€reached,€the€Forum€will€return€to€the€Board€with€the€results.€€JohnĞ ¸#! Ğnoted€that€the€presentation€was€an€update€of€the€Forumğğs€work€and€that€specific€action€byĞ ¨$ø" Ğthe€WRAP€was€not€being€requested.€€İƒ3£Ézöz݌И%è #(#(# ĞŒİ  İÌà0  àDoug€Lempke€asked€if€the€Federal€Land€Managers€had€been€queried€about€using€theĞ x'È"% ĞFLAG€approach€cited€by€John€in€his€presentation.€€John€said€the€Forum€had€not€askedĞ h(¸#& Ğthem€specifically.€€Chris€Shaver€said€that€it€really€was€a€policy€decision€and€should€beĞ X)¨$' Ğdiscussed€by€the€Forum€as€such.€€John€said€that€it€would€be€helpful€to€have€aĞ H*˜%( Ğrepresentative€from€the€Federal€Land€Managers€to€discuss€the€FLAG€approach€in€moreĞ 8+ˆ&) Ğdetail.€€Andy€Ginsburg€asked€if€the€issue€would€have€significant€impacts€on€decision„Ğ (,x'* Ğmakers.€€John€responded€that€if€conformity€and€SIP€revisions€were€involved,€there€couldĞ ° Ğbe€problems.€€Ğ ğ(#(# ĞÌà0  àLucille€Van€Ommering€asked€if€dust€was€going€to€be€a€significant€contributor.€€JohnĞ €Ğ Ğresponded€that€the€experts€believe€dust€impacts€are€going€to€be€the€greatest€from€sourcesĞ pÀ Ğnear€a€Class€I€area.€€John€added€that€dust€should€be€catalogued€for€individual€states,€butĞ ` ° Ğthat€strategies€could€be€focused€on€sources€in€and€near€the€Class€I€area.€€By€looking€atĞ P   Ğstatewide€emissions,€it€should€be€possible€to€characterize€the€nature€of€the€problem€andĞ @  Ğthe€areas€most€significantly€contributing.€€Ğ0 €(#(# ĞÌà0  àAndy€Ginsburg€asked€if€the€policy€issues€were€going€to€be€similar€with€regard€to€clean€airĞ `  Ğcorridors.€€John€responded€that€there€should€at€least€be€consistency€in€how€significance€isĞ P  Ğdefined,€but€that€the€Forum€had€not€given€the€issue€much€attention.€€Lewis€McLeod€askedĞ ğ@  Ğhow€the€lack€of€data€from€tribal€areas€will€impact€development€of€an€accurate€inventory.Ğ à0  ĞJohn€said€that€decisions€on€control€strategy€development€would€have€to€be€made€basedĞ Ğ  Ğon€the€availability€of€data.€€ĞÀ(#(# ĞÌİ"‚3£"İİ  İİ‚3£2†İÔ2ï;ÔÚ  Ú16Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òRecommendations€from€Northern€Air€Managersó óóó.€€Dan€Olson€made€the€presentationĞ  ğ Ğ(slide€show€available€on€Web€site).€€The€basic€change€would€have€a€state€caucus€and€aĞ ˜è Ğtribal€caucus,€each€with€staff€support€that€would€communicate€with€each€other.€€TheĞ ˆØ Ğcaucuses€would€come€together€as€the€air€managers€group.€The€EPA€and€FLMs€would€beĞ xÈ Ğpart€of€the€air€managers€group€as€ex€officio€members.€€The€air€managers€group€wouldĞ h¸ Ğthen€report€back€through€the€WRAP€standing€committees.€€İƒ3£2†_†İŒĞX¨(#(# ĞŒİ  İÌà0  àChris€Shaver€suggested€that€the€air€managers€committee€would€function€as€a€shadowĞ 8ˆ Ğorganization€to€the€Board,€but€that€it€does€not€represent€a€stakeholder€committee.€€DanĞ (x Ğclarified€that€the€meetings€would€be€open€to€any€stakeholder€to€attend,€but€that€theĞ h Ğstakeholders€would€not€achieve€membership.€€Dan€also€said€that€the€group€would€notĞ X Ğduplicate€the€standing€committees,€but€would€identify€issues€to€be€vetted€through€theĞ øH Ğstanding€committees.€€Ğè8(#(# ĞÌà0  àDoug€Lempke€expressed€a€concern€that€many€of€the€people€who€wind€up€sitting€on€theĞ È! ĞBoard€would€also€be€representing€states€at€the€air€managers€meetings,€and€that€decisionsĞ ¸"  Ğcould€be€made€essentially€in€advance€of€Board€meetings.€€Nina€Daugherty€commentedĞ ¨#ø! Ğthat€decisions€needed€to€be€made€cognizant€of€the€broader€views€of€other€stakeholders.€Ğ ˜$è" ĞDan€responded€that€the€air€managers€group€was€not€decision„making,€but€would€identifyĞ ˆ%Ø # Ğissues€that€ultimately€needed€full€stakeholder€resolution.€€Al€Zemsky€noted€that€theĞ x&È!$ ĞCommunications€Committee€would€be€making€recommendations€to€have€more€meetingĞ h'¸"% Ğsummaries€available€as€opposed€to€just€meeting€minutes.€€ĞX(¨#&(#(# ĞÌà0  àThe€Board€approved€the€structure€proposed€by€the€Northern€Air€Managers.€€RandyĞ 8*ˆ%( ĞAshley€was€nominated€by€Lewis€McLeod€to€be€the€Tribal€co„chair.€€Sandra€Ely€wasĞ (+x&) Ğnominated€by€Dan€Olson€to€be€the€state€co„chair.€€Doug€Lempke€moved,€Chris€ShaverĞ ,h'* Ğseconded€the€nominations.€The€motion€was€approved€unanimously.€€Ğ°(#(# ĞÌİ"‚3£"İİ  İİ‚3£iİÔ2ï;ÔÚ  Ú17Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òDiscussion€of€State€and€Tribal€308/309€decision€processes€and€information€neededĞ à Ğfrom€the€WRAPó óóó.€€Andy€Ginsburg€did€an€introductory€presentation€(presentation€availableĞ ˆØ Ğon€Web€site)€covering€the€following€issues:€€İƒ3£i–݌ЀĞ(#(# ĞŒİ  İÌØ#ÿÿ #Øİ"‚é;ÿÿ"İİ  İİ‚é;`’İà0  àÔ2ï;Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İimportance€of€the€decision€(critical€mass€in€choosing€309,€opportunity€for€regionalĞ ` ° Ğapproach,€economic€and€workload€issues,€WRAP€assistance€to€states€and€tribes)݃é;`’’İŒĞP  ` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚é;"İİ  İİ‚é;ß“İà0  àÔ2ï;Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İprocess€to€meet€the€2003€SIP/TIP€deadline݃é;ß“ ”İŒĞ@ ` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚é;"İİ  İİ‚é;Ò”İà0  àÔ2ï;Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İ308€v.€309€considerations€(Under€308,€more€time€to€submit€a€SIP€[not€later€thanĞ 0 €  Ğ2008],€strategies€are€to€be€determined,€BART€must€be€addressed,€must€showĞ  p  Ğreasonable€progress€on€the€slope€through€2064,€there€needs€to€be€regionalĞ `  Ğcoordination,€the€WRAP€will€be€responsible€for€some€of€the€work,€and€there€areĞ P  Ğprobably€greater€economic€impacts€for€states€having€to€prepare€the€plans.€€UnderĞ ğ@  Ğ309,€SIPs€are€due€in€2003,€the€strategies€are€already€identified,€submission€of€theĞ à0  ĞAnnex€satisfies€BART,€it€assumes€reasonable€progress€through€2018,€need€aĞ Ğ  Ğcritical€mass€of€states,€the€WRAP€does€most€of€the€work,€and€it€will€probably€beĞ À Ğless€expensive€for€states.)݃é;Ò”ÿ”݌а` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚é;"İİ  İİ‚é;ʘİà0  àÔ2ï;Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İtribes€are€under€a€different€timeline€than€states݃é;ʘ÷˜İŒĞ ğ` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İÌà0  àNancy€Wrona€from€Arizona€talked€about€the€public€process€for€determining€whether€toĞ €Ğ Ğgo€308€or€309€(slide€presentation€available€on€the€Web€site).€€Major€points€included:ĞpÀ(#(# ĞÓ€ (.)x0Óİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£/›İÔ2.)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İdecision€timing݃3£/›h›İŒĞ`°` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£œİÔ2.)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İstakeholder€process€and€issues݃3£œAœİŒĞP ` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£ğœİÔ2.)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İeducating€stakeholders€to€keep€everyone€on€a€level€field݃3£ğœ)İŒĞ@` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£òİÔ2.)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İsix€meetings€were€held€between€August€and€November€7݃3£ò+İŒĞ0€` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£ğİÔ2.)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İoptions€available€under€308€and€309€respectively݃3£ğ)ŸİŒĞ p` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£êŸİÔ2.)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İconsensus€building€process݃3£êŸ# İŒĞ`` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£Î İÔ2.)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İthe€preferred€option€turned€out€to€be€going€Section€309€with€all€Class€I€areas݃3£Î ¡İŒĞP` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3£æ¡İÔ2.)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İSIP€development€work€plan€and€timeline€needed€to€be€developed€as€soon€asĞ ğ@ Ğpossible݃3£æ¡¢İŒĞà 0` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İİ"‚3£"İİ  İà0  àİ‚3££İÔ2.)Ôğ2ğÔ3  Ôà0` (#(#àİ  İthere€needed€to€be€gubernatorial€support€for€stakeholder€supported€legislation݃3££N£İŒĞĞ! ` (#` (# ĞŒİ  İÌà0  àDennis€Hemmer€asked€how€confident€Arizona€is€about€being€able€to€complete€a€309€SIPĞ °#! Ğon€the€required€timeline.€€Nancy€responded€that€there€were€certainly€issues,€but€theyĞ  $ğ" Ğwould€do€everything€possible€to€make€it€work.€€Wayne€Leipold€emphasized€that€largerĞ %à # Ğindustrial€sources€favored€309€because€of€the€certainty€it€provides.€€Chris€ShaverĞ €&Ğ!$ Ğrequested€that€the€Arizona€experience€be€posted€on€the€WRAP€Web€page.Ğp'À"%(#(# ĞÌÓ€ "(•h8x ÓØ! !Øİ"‚3£"İİ  İİ‚3£â¦İÔ2•hÔÚ  Ú18Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òThe€next€meeting€was€set€for€June€18„19€in€Coloradoó óóó.݃3£â¦§İŒĞP) $'(#(# ĞŒİ  İÌİ"‚3£"İİ  İİ‚3£í§İÔ2•hÔÚ  Ú19Ú  Ú.Ô3  Ôà0  àİ  İòòò òThe€meeting€was€adjourned€at€2:00.ó óóó݃3£í§¨İŒĞ8+ˆ&)(#(# ĞŒİ  İĞ  0,€'* Ğò òAttendees:Ğ ° ĞÌÒ(X°(#°(#(ÒBoard€Members:Ğ à Ğó óGov.€Cyrus€J.€Chino,€Pueblo€of€AcomaĞ €Ğ ĞGov.€Michael€Leavitt,€UtahĞ pÀ ĞDianne€Nielson,€Utah€DEQĞ ` ° ĞStanley€Paytiamo,€Pueblo€of€AcomaĞ P   ĞBob€Saunders,€Washington€DOEĞ @  ĞKesner€Flores,€Cortina€RancheriaĞ 0 € ĞLynn€Terry,€CARBĞ  p  ĞFarshid€Farsi,€Shoshone„BannockĞ `  ĞRobert€Wilkosz,€Idaho€DEQĞ P  ĞJack€McGraw,€EPAĞ ğ@  ĞSylvia€Palmer,€Hualapai€TribeĞ à0  ĞTom€Chapple,€AlaskaĞ Ğ  ĞDennis€Hemmer,€Wyoming€DEQĞ À ĞDoug€Lempke,€Colorado€DPHEĞ ° ĞAndrew€Ginsburg,€Oregon,€DEQĞ  ğ ĞLloyd€Irvine,€Confederated€Salish€&Ğ à ĞKootenai€TribesĞ €Ğ ĞWarren€Harper,€Forest€ServiceĞ pÀ ĞRalph€Gruebel,€New€Mexico€DEQĞ `° ĞChris€Shaver,€National€Park€ServiceĞ P  ĞBob€Raisch,€Montana€DEQĞ @ ĞDana€Mount,€North€Dakota€DOHĞ 0€ ĞNancy€Wrona,€ArizonaĞ  p ĞGilbert€Pablo,€Campo€Band€of€KumeyaayĞ ` ĞIndiansĞ P ĞJay€Littlewolf,€Northern€Cheyenne€TribeĞ ğ@ ĞÌò òOther€Participants:ó óĞ Ğ  ĞLewis€McLeod,€CS&K€TribesĞ À! ĞBarry€Aarons,€The€Aarons€CompanyĞ °"  ĞDennis€Schwehr,€West€AssociatesĞ  #ğ! ĞBob€Neufeld,€Wyoming€RefiningĞ $à" ĞTom€Webb,€EPAĞ €%Ğ # ĞPat€MurdoĞ p&À!$ ĞDan€Clark,€Wyoming€DEQĞ `'°"% ĞSandra€Ely,€New€Mexico€DEQĞ P( #& ĞDan€Johnson,€WESTARĞ @)$' ĞTerry€Ross,€CEEDĞ 0*€%( ĞLaura€Tsosie,€Hualapai€NationĞ  +p&) ĞDan€Olson,€Wyoming€DEQĞ ,`'* ĞKerry€Kelly,€University€of€UtahĞ à* ĞGreg€Schaefer,€Arch€CoalĞ €Ğ+ ĞNick€Bettas,€P&M€Coal€MiningĞ pÀ, ĞBonnie€Thie,€EPAĞ ` °- ĞPat€Hanrahan,€Oregon€DEQĞ P  . ĞJulie€Simpson,€Nez€PerceĞ @ / ĞRichard€Long,€EPAĞ 0 €0 ĞCyra€Cain,€Montana€DEQĞ  p1 ĞKathy€Van€Dame,€Wasatch€Clean€AirĞ ` 2 ĞNina€Daugherty,€Sierra€ClubĞ P 3 ĞAmy€Zimpfer,€EPAĞ ğ@ 4 ĞColleen€Delaney,€Utah€DEQĞ à0 5 ĞBob€Ramirez,€Salt€River„Pima€Ğ Ğ 6 ĞJill€Sherman,€Pechanga€BandĞ À7 ĞBrock€LeBaron,€Utah€DEQĞ °8 ĞCheryl€Heying,€Utah€DEQĞ  ğ9 ĞWayne€Leipold,€Phelps€DodgeĞ à: ĞRich€Fisher,€U.S.€Forest€ServiceĞ €Ğ; ĞLee€Gribovicz,€Wyoming€DEQĞ pÀ< ĞIra€Domsky,€Arizona€DEQĞ `°= ĞPete€Lahm,€U.S.€Forest€ServiceĞ P > ĞCarl€Bowman,€National€Park€ServiceĞ @? ĞSandra€Lucas,€Trenton€WestĞ 0€@ ĞMike€George,€Arizona€DEQĞ  pA ĞJohn€Kowalczyk,€Oregon€DEQĞ `B ĞBill€Edmonds,€PacifiCorpĞ PC ĞReuben€Plantico,€PacifiCorpĞ ğ@D ĞMarius€Gedgaudas,€USAECĞ à0E ĞAl€Zemsky,€EPAĞ Ğ F ĞDarla€Potter,€Wyoming€DEQĞ À!G ĞErnie€Wessman,€PacifiCorpĞ °"H ĞOndrea€Barber,€ITCAĞ  #ğI ĞBill€Grantham,€NTECĞ $àJ ĞPatrick€Cummins,€WGAĞ €%Ğ K ĞRich€Halvey,€WGAĞ p&À!L ĞKaren€Deike,€WGAĞ `'°"M ĞLucille€Van€Ommering,€CARBòòóó